Proracle’s Weblog

March 12, 2008

Causes of Oracle buffer busy waits

Filed under: useful — proracle @ 2:56 am

Takeaway: Resolving buffer busy wait events in an Oracle database can be vital to your optimization efforts. Insight into the causes of this performance problem is provided in this examination by Oracle guru Don Burleson.
One of the most confounding problems with Oracle is the resolution of buffer busy wait events. Buffer busy waits are common in an I/O-bound Oracle system, as evidenced by any system with read (sequential/scattered) waits in the top-five waits in the Oracle STATSPACK report, like this:
Top 5 Timed Events
% Total
Event                         Waits        Time (s)     Ela Time
————————— ———— ———– ———–
db file sequential read       2,598        7,146           48.54
db file scattered read       25,519        3,246           22.04
library cache load lock         673        1,363            9.26
CPU time                      2,154          934            7.83
log file parallel write      19,157          837            5.68

The main way to reduce buffer busy waits is to reduce the total I/O on the system. This can be done by tuning the SQL to access rows with fewer block reads (i.e., by adding indexes). Even if we have a huge db_cache_size, we may still see buffer busy waits, and increasing the buffer size won’t help.

In order to look at systemwide wait events, we can query the v$system_event performance view. This view, shown in Listing A, provides the name of the wait event, the total number of waits and timeouts, the total time waited, and the average wait time per event.

The type of buffer that causes the wait can be queried using the v$waitstat view. This view lists the waits per buffer type for buffer busy waits, where COUNT is the sum of all waits for the class of block, and TIME is the sum of all wait times for that class:
select * from v$waitstat;

CLASS                   COUNT       TIME
—————— ———- ———-
data block            1961113    1870278
segment header          34535     159082
undo header            233632      86239
undo block               1886       1706

Buffer busy waits occur when an Oracle session needs to access a block in the buffer cache, but cannot because the buffer copy of the data block is locked. This buffer busy wait condition can happen for either of the following reasons:

  • The block is being read into the buffer by another session, so the waiting session must wait for the block read to complete.
  • Another session has the buffer block locked in a mode that is incompatible with the waiting session’s request.

Because buffer busy waits are due to contention between particular blocks, there’s nothing you can do until you know which blocks are in conflict and why the conflicts are occurring. Tuning therefore involves identifying and eliminating the cause of the block contention.

The v$session_wait performance view, shown in Listing B, can give some insight into what is being waited for and why the wait is occurring.

The columns of the v$session_wait view that are of particular interest for a buffer busy wait event are:

  • P1-The absolute file number for the data file involved in the wait.
  • P2-The block number within the data file referenced in P1 that is being waited upon.
  • P3-The reason code describing why the wait is occurring.

Here’s an Oracle data dictionary query for these values:
p1 “File #”.
p2 “Block #”,
p3 “Reason Code”
event = ‘buffer busy waits’;

If the output from repeatedly running the above query shows that a block or range of blocks is experiencing waits, the following query should show the name and type of the segment:
file_id = &P1
&P2 between block_id and block_id + blocks -1;

Once the segment is identified, the v$segment_statistics performance view facilitates real-time monitoring of segment-level statistics. This enables a DBA to identify performance problems associated with individual tables or indexes, as shown in Listing C.

We can also query (Listing D) dba_data_files to determine the file_name for the file involved in the wait by using the P1 value from v$session_wait for the file_id.

Interrogating the P3 (reason code) value from v$session_wait for a buffer busy wait event will tell us why the session is waiting. The reason codes range from 0 to 300 and can be decoded, as shown in Table A.
Table A

Code Reason for wait
A modification is happening on a SCUR or XCUR buffer but has not yet completed.
0 The block is being read into the buffer cache.
100 We want to NEW the block, but the block is currently being read by another session (most likely for undo).
110 We want the CURRENT block either shared or exclusive but the block is being read into cache by another session, so we have to wait until its read() is completed.
120 We want to get the block in current mode, but someone else is currently reading it into the cache. Wait for the user to complete the read. This occurs during buffer lookup.
130 Block is being read by another session, and no other suitable block image was found, so we wait until the read is completed. This may also occur after a buffer cache assumed deadlock. The kernel can’t get a buffer in a certain amount of time and assumes a deadlock. Therefore it will read the CR version of the block.
200 We want to NEW the block, but someone else is using the current copy, so we have to wait for that user to finish.
210 The session wants the block in SCUR or XCUR mode. If this is a buffer exchange or the session is in discrete TX mode, the session waits for the first time and the second time escalates the block as a deadlock, so does not show up as waiting very long. In this case, the statistic: “exchange deadlocks” is incremented, and we yield the CPU for the “buffer deadlock” wait event.
220 During buffer lookup for a CURRENT copy of a buffer, we have found the buffer but someone holds it in an incompatible mode, so we have to wait.
230 Trying to get a buffer in CR/CRX mode, but a modification has started on the buffer that has not yet been completed.
231 CR/CRX scan found the CURRENT block, but a modification has started on the buffer that has not yet been completed.

Reason codes

As I mentioned at the beginning of this article, buffer busy waits are prevalent in I/O-bound systems. I/O contention, resulting in waits for data blocks, is often due to numerous sessions repeatedly reading the same blocks, as when many sessions scan the same index. In this scenario, session one scans the blocks in the buffer cache quickly, but then a block has to be read from disk. While session one awaits the disk read to complete, other sessions scanning the same index soon catch up to session one and want the same block currently being read from disk. This is where the buffer busy wait occurs-waiting for the buffer blocks that are being read from disk.

The following rules of thumb may be useful for resolving each of the noted contention situations:

  • Data block contention-Identify and eliminate HOT blocks from the application via changing PCTFREE and or PCTUSED values to reduce the number of rows per data block. Check for repeatedly scanned indexes. Since each transaction updating a block requires a transaction entry, increase the INITRANS value.
  • Freelist block contention-Increase the FREELISTS value. Also, when using Parallel Server, be certain that each instance has its own FREELIST GROUPs.
  • Segment header contention-Again, increase the number of FREELISTs and use FREELIST GROUPs, which can make a difference even within a single instance.
  • Undo header contention-Increase the number of rollback segments.

The identification and resolution of buffer busy waits can be very complex and confusing. Oracle provides the v$segment_statistics view to help monitor buffer busy waits, and the v$system_event views to identify the specific blocks for the buffer busy wait. While identifying and correcting the causes of buffer busy waits is not an intuitive process, the results of your efforts can be quite rewarding.

Listing A

select * from    v$system_event where    event like '%wait%';   EVENT                       TOTAL_WAITS TOTAL_TIMEOUTS TIME_WAITED AVERAGE_WAIT --------------------------- ----------- -------------- ----------- ------------ buffer busy waits                636528           1557      549700   .863591232 write complete waits               1193              0       14799   12.4048617 free buffer waits                  1601              0         622   .388507183

Listing B

SQL> desc v$session_wait    Name                                      Null?       Type  -------------------------------------- -------- ---------------  SID                                                NUMBER  SEQ#                                               NUMBER  EVENT                                              VARCHAR2(64)  P1TEXT                                             VARCHAR2(64)  P1                                                 NUMBER  P1RAW                                              RAW(4)  P2TEXT                                             VARCHAR2(64)  P2                                                 NUMBER  P2RAW                                              RAW(4)  P3TEXT                                             VARCHAR2(64)  P3                                                 NUMBER  P3RAW                                              RAW(4)  WAIT_TIME                                          NUMBER  SECONDS_IN_WAIT                                    NUMBER  STATE                                              VARCHAR2(19)

Listing C

select    object_name,    statistic_name,    value from    V$SEGMENT_STATISTICS where    object_name = 'SOURCE$';   OBJECT_NAME      STATISTIC_NAME             VALUE -----------  -------------------------       ---------- SOURCE$      logical reads                    11216 SOURCE$      buffer busy waits                  210 SOURCE$      db block changes                    32 SOURCE$      physical reads                   10365 SOURCE$      physical writes                      0 SOURCE$      physical reads direct                0 SOURCE$      physical writes direct               0 SOURCE$      ITL waits                            0 SOURCE$      row lock waits                       0

Listing D

SQL> desc dba_data_files    Name                                      Null?    Type  --------------------------------------- -------- ---------------  FILE_NAME                                          VARCHAR2(513)  FILE_ID                                            NUMBER  TABLESPACE_NAME                                    VARCHAR2(30)  BYTES                                              NUMBER  BLOCKS                                             NUMBER  STATUS                                             VARCHAR2(9)  RELATIVE_FNO                                       NUMBER  AUTOEXTENSIBLE                                     VARCHAR2(3)  MAXBYTES                                           NUMBER  MAXBLOCKS                                          NUMBER  INCREMENT_BY                                       NUMBER  USER_BYTES                                         NUMBER  USER_BLOCKS                                        NUMBER
Next Page »

Blog at